The list of who's been the most valuable and least valuable the most times thus far:

MVOP:

1. Marco Scutaro, Nick Swisher, Eric Byrnes -- 1

LVOP:

1. Mark Ellis, Erubiel Durazo, Bobby Kielty -- 1

MVP:

1. Kiko Calero, Kirk Saarloos, Dan Haren -- 1

LVP:

1. Barry Zito -- 1